Why does our leadership team keep having the same strategy conversation?

A revolving door party. Strategic decision-making as a revolving door, with people continuously going round and round.
Revolving Door Party by Scott Beale

If your executive team keeps returning to the same strategic debates, and strategic decision-making keeps stalling, the cause is rarely a lack of data or too many difficult people. More often, the team is arguing over uncertain choices as if it could prove one option right in advance. Treat each choice as a hypothesis with agreed evidence and a date to review it, make the strategy visible on one page, and, if you’re stuck, bring in an independent facilitator with no stake in which option wins.

Signs your leadership team is going round in circles

The same item appears on the agenda month after month. Each time people discuss it with energy, and each time it rolls over to the next meeting.

Or the team does make a decision, and then someone quietly reopens it a few weeks later. Sometimes it’s someone who missed the meeting. Sometimes it’s someone who was there and nodded along, but was never really convinced.

Another version is agreement in the room followed by different actions afterwards. Everyone leaves thinking they’ve aligned, and then each function does something slightly different with what it heard.

And when the team finally settles on a choice, it’s often because the loudest voice won, or the HiPPO (the highest-paid person’s opinion). Everyone else then goes along with it without really committing, and it rarely survives the first bad month.

None of this means the team is bad at strategic decision-making. In my experience, it usually means capable people are trying to solve an uncertain problem as if it had a knowable right answer.

Why does strategic decision-making get stuck?

Mostly, it’s because strategic choices are uncertain. Nobody can know in advance whether entering a new market, or restructuring around customer segments, will work. People with different experience will reasonably see different futures. So nobody wins a debate about which option is “right” by arguing harder, and more analysis tends to give each side more ammunition rather than settling anything.

It doesn’t help when there’s no shared picture of the strategy. It lives in a slide deck from the last offsite, in a few documents, and in each person’s head. Every conversation has to reconstruct the context before it can get anywhere, and each person reconstructs it slightly differently.

Then there’s the lack of any point at which the team reviews a decision. If a choice is effectively permanent, the stakes of getting it wrong feel very high. It’s rational to hold out, or to reopen it when new information appears, because there’s no other legitimate place for that information to go.

And finally there’s loyalty to individual functions. Each member of the executive team also represents a part of the organisation, and people judge options partly by what they mean for their part. I don’t see that as people being difficult. It’s what we ask of people when we put them in charge of a function.

How to break the strategic decision-making loop

I don’t think there’s a single trick. The aim is for each conversation to build on the last one, rather than starting from scratch.

Make the strategy visible on one page

I use the TASTE X-Matrix for this. It captures True North, Aspirations, Strategies, Tactics, and Evidence on a single page, along with how they relate to each other. When the strategy is visible, the next conversation can pick up where the last one left off.

It also makes disagreements more specific. Instead of a general argument about direction, the question becomes something like “do we believe this tactic really contributes to that aspiration?” Those relationships are judgements, not calculations, but at least they’re judgements everyone can see and discuss.

Frame options as hypotheses

You can write a strategic choice as a hypothesis. We believe that this strategy, implemented through these tactics, will move us towards these aspirations. We’ll know we’re on track if we see this evidence by this date.

This shifts the conversation from who is right to what would tell us. In my experience, it’s much easier for a leadership team to agree on what evidence would matter than to agree on what the future holds. And once the team agrees on that, strategic decision-making gets much easier, because a decision no longer feels permanent and risky. It becomes a bet the team has chosen to place, with a clear point at which to look again.

Separate strategic decision-making from reviewing

This is where a regular rhythm matters. With Continuous Strategy, everyone takes part in reviewing and refreshing the strategy continuously, on an agreed cadence. Between reviews, decisions stand, and tactics get on with implementing them. At the review, the team looks at the evidence and adjusts.

That rhythm is part of what I’d call the organisation’s operating model, meaning its capability to run its strategy. It’s the cadences, interactions and artefacts around the X-Matrix, along with the decision rights, governance and structure that support them. When the operating model gives new information somewhere to go, strategic decision-making stops spilling over into corridor conversations.

Check understanding after the meeting

Agreement in the room isn’t the same as aligned action. Backbriefing closes that gap. After a decision, each leader plays back what they understood, what they intend to do, and what they need from others. Misunderstandings surface in days rather than months.

Catchball extends the same idea through the organisation, passing the strategy back and forth between levels until people can see how their work connects to it, which builds decision-making capacity further down the organisation. It’s also one of the best ways I know to notice when strategy and work start drifting apart.

Why does an independent facilitator help?

The most obvious reason is that an independent facilitator has no stake in which option wins. They’re not protecting a budget or a team, so they can hold the process without anyone suspecting them of steering the outcome.

They can also name the pattern. It’s hard for a member of the executive team to say “this is the third time we’ve had this conversation” without it sounding like a complaint about colleagues. From the outside, it’s simply an observation.

And it frees the CEO to take part. When a CEO chairs their own strategy discussion, they tend either to steer it or to hold back so as not to steer it. Neither helps. With someone else holding the process, the CEO can contribute as a full member of the team.

If you’re wary of consultants, that’s reasonable. A good facilitator shouldn’t arrive with the answer, or take over your strategic decision-making. The strategy has to be yours, or nobody will own it when it gets difficult.

What does this look like in practice?

I worked with an internal coaching team and its leadership in a large pharmaceutical organisation. They kept debating what the coaching team should focus on and what success would look like. It kept coming back, and never quite landed.

Putting the strategy onto an X-Matrix helped show why. People were using the same words to mean different things, and there was confusion about the difference between the TASTE elements. Flow metrics were a good example. Were they evidence, telling us whether the strategy was working? Or were they a tactic, something the team would do? Until that was clear, people were effectively having two different conversations.

And if flow metrics were evidence, the next question followed naturally. Which tactics did we expect to contribute to them? That turned out to be a far more useful conversation than a general one about focus.

The review helped realign everyone and refocus on what to do next.

There is a different example in the Rally case study.

Who can help a UK leadership team with this?

This is the work I do. I’m based in Brighton, and most of it is with UK leadership teams, helping them make their strategy visible, treat their choices as hypotheses, and review them on a regular rhythm. The TASTE X-Matrix and Continuous Strategy grew out of that work, building on the Strategy Deployment I first learned at Rally Software.

You can find out more about how I help, or about Strategy Deployment more generally.

If your leadership team keeps having the same strategy conversation, I’d be happy to talk through your strategy.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.